They Say / I Say

They Say / I Say

Summary of “They Say / I Say” by Gerald Graff

Main Topic or Theme of the Book

They Say / I Say is to provide readers with a comprehensive guide on how to engage in academic writing effectively. Graff emphasizes the importance of understanding and participating in the ongoing scholarly conversation through mastering rhetorical strategies.

Key Ideas or Arguments Presented

  • Mastering the “They Say / I Say” Framework: Graff introduces the concept of the “they say/I say” framework, which emphasizes the necessity of responding to existing arguments before presenting one’s own. This framework serves as a foundation for constructing persuasive academic writing.
  • Academic Writing as Conversation: Graff portrays academic writing as a conversation among scholars. He underscores the significance of recognizing the existing arguments (the “they say”) and articulating one’s own perspective (the “I say”) within this ongoing discourse.
  • Templates and Strategies: The book provides readers with practical templates and strategies for structuring their arguments and responses. These templates offer a scaffolding for organizing ideas coherently and persuasively.

Chapter Titles or Main Sections of the Book

  • Chapter 1: “They Say”: Introduces the concept of responding to existing arguments.
  • Chapter 2: “Her Point Is”: Emphasizes the importance of understanding and engaging with differing perspectives.
  • Chapter 3: “As He Himself Puts It”: Focuses on quoting and paraphrasing effectively.
  • Chapter 4: “Yes / No / Okay, But”: Explores strategies for agreeing, disagreeing, or both with existing arguments.
  • Chapter 5: “And Yet”: Discusses how to introduce one’s own perspective while acknowledging opposing viewpoints.
  • Chapter 6: “Skeptics May Object”: Addresses potential objections and counterarguments.
  • Chapter 7: “So What? Who Cares?”: Encourages writers to consider the significance and relevance of their arguments.

Key Takeaways or Conclusions

  • Effective Engagement in Academic Discourse: By mastering the “they say/I say” framework, readers can actively participate in academic discourse, contributing meaningfully to ongoing conversations within their fields.
  • Development of Rhetorical Skills: Graff’s provision of templates and strategies equips readers with the necessary rhetorical skills to construct well-organized and persuasive arguments.
  • Enhanced Writing Confidence: Through understanding and applying the principles outlined in the book, writers can develop confidence in their ability to navigate complex academic discussions and articulate their ideas effectively.

Author’s Background and Qualifications

  • Gerald Graff is a distinguished professor of English and education at the University of Illinois at Chicago.
  • With a background in teaching writing and rhetoric, Graff brings extensive expertise to his exploration of academic discourse in “They Say / I Say.”

Comparison to Other Books on the Same Subject

  • “They Say / I Say” distinguishes itself through its focus on practical strategies for engaging in academic writing. Unlike some other writing guides, Graff’s book provides clear templates and frameworks tailored specifically to the conventions of scholarly discourse.

Target Audience or Intended Readership

  • The book is intended for students, scholars, and anyone seeking to improve their academic writing skills.
  • It caters to individuals at various skill levels, from beginners in academic writing to seasoned scholars looking to refine their rhetorical techniques.

Explanation and Analysis of Each Part with Quotes

Chapter 1: “They Say”

  • Explanation: This chapter introduces the “they say/I say” framework, suggesting that academic writing is essentially a dialogue. Graff argues that effective academic writing involves responding to the ideas of others before presenting one’s own perspective. He emphasizes the importance of acknowledging and engaging with existing arguments as a fundamental aspect of scholarly discourse.
  • Analysis: By starting with the “they say” portion, writers signal their awareness of the existing conversation within their field and establish credibility by demonstrating familiarity with relevant scholarship. This sets the stage for constructing a persuasive argument that contributes meaningfully to ongoing discussions.
  • Quote: “To enter the conversation, they [students] need to acknowledge the existence of their fellow conversationalists – their ‘they say’ – before making their own contribution – their ‘I say.'”

Chapter 2: “Her Point Is”

  • Explanation: This chapter focuses on the skill of summarizing and understanding the arguments of others accurately. Graff emphasizes the importance of representing opposing viewpoints fairly and avoiding misrepresentation. He highlights the role of summarizing as a means of demonstrating comprehension and engaging critically with existing scholarship.
  • Analysis: Accurate summarization not only shows respect for the ideas of others but also provides a foundation for constructing a well-informed response. It allows writers to identify key points of agreement or disagreement and facilitates the development of a nuanced argument.
  • Quote: “To give writing the focus it deserves, we need to see it as entering a conversation, engaging others in dialogues about issues and ideas.”

Chapter 3: “As He Himself Puts It”

  • Explanation: This chapter explores the techniques of quoting and paraphrasing effectively. Graff provides guidance on integrating sources seamlessly into one’s own writing while maintaining clarity and coherence. He emphasizes the importance of accurately representing the ideas of others and providing appropriate attribution.
  • Analysis: Quoting and paraphrasing serve as evidence to support one’s arguments and lend credibility to the writer’s perspective. By skillfully incorporating sources, writers demonstrate their engagement with existing scholarship and enrich their own arguments with the insights of others.
  • Quote: “Good academic writing has one underlying feature: It is deeply engaged in some way with other people’s views.”

Chapter 4: “Yes / No / Okay, But”

  • Explanation: This chapter discusses strategies for agreeing, disagreeing, or both with existing arguments. Graff encourages writers to engage critically with the ideas of others and to articulate their own perspective thoughtfully. He emphasizes the importance of providing reasons and evidence to support one’s position.
  • Analysis: Responding to others’ arguments demonstrates critical thinking and allows writers to position themselves within ongoing scholarly debates. By acknowledging the complexity of issues and presenting well-reasoned responses, writers strengthen their own arguments and contribute to the advancement of knowledge in their field.
  • Quote: “The best academic writers are more like lawyers who argue for a position than like judges who decide what is right or wrong.”

Chapter 5: “And Yet”

  • Explanation: This chapter addresses how to introduce one’s own perspective while acknowledging opposing viewpoints. Graff emphasizes the importance of complexity and nuance in academic writing, encouraging writers to recognize the validity of differing perspectives. He suggests that acknowledging opposing viewpoints adds depth and credibility to one’s argument.
  • Analysis: Acknowledging opposing viewpoints demonstrates intellectual honesty and enhances the persuasiveness of one’s argument. By engaging with differing perspectives, writers demonstrate a willingness to grapple with complex issues and contribute to a more nuanced understanding of the topic.
  • Quote: “By ‘entering the conversation,’ we mean more than just inserting your views into an ongoing debate.”

Chapter 6: “Skeptics May Object”

  • Explanation: This chapter deals with addressing potential objections and counterarguments. Graff encourages writers to anticipate and respond to critiques effectively, thereby strengthening their own arguments. He suggests that addressing counterarguments demonstrates the writer’s thorough understanding of the topic and enhances the persuasiveness of their argument.
  • Analysis: Addressing counterarguments demonstrates critical thinking and allows writers to preemptively address potential objections from readers. By engaging with opposing viewpoints, writers demonstrate intellectual rigor and enhance the credibility of their own arguments.
  • Quote: “The best writers see objections not as roadblocks but as opportunities to deepen their own arguments and engage their audiences more effectively.”

Chapter 7: “So What? Who Cares?”

  • Explanation: This chapter encourages writers to consider the significance and relevance of their arguments. Graff suggests that connecting academic writing to real-world concerns enhances its impact and persuasiveness. He emphasizes the importance of demonstrating the broader implications of one’s argument and engaging readers’ interest.
  • Analysis: Demonstrating the relevance and significance of one’s argument adds depth and persuasiveness to academic writing. By connecting their ideas to real-world issues and concerns, writers demonstrate the practical importance of their work and engage readers on a deeper level.
  • Quote: “To write persuasively is to engage others in your concerns.”

These chapters collectively provide a detailed exploration of the strategies and techniques involved in engaging effectively with academic writing. By mastering the principles outlined in “They Say / I Say,” writers can enhance the clarity, coherence, and persuasiveness of their arguments, contributing meaningfully to scholarly discourse.

The Book from the Perspective of Mothers

  • Mothers, often the unsung heroes of their children’s academic journeys, can wield significant influence in supporting their children’s development in various academic skills, including writing.
  • “They Say / I Say” can serve as a valuable resource for mothers seeking to understand the intricacies of academic writing and provide meaningful guidance to their children.
  • By familiarizing themselves with the concepts presented in the book, mothers can engage in informed discussions with their children about the importance of responding to existing arguments and constructing persuasive essays.
  • Mothers can play a pivotal role in instilling confidence in their children’s writing abilities by encouraging them to practice the techniques outlined in “They Say / I Say” and providing constructive feedback.
  • Additionally, mothers can use the book as a tool to facilitate discussions with their children about the relevance and significance of their academic work, helping them recognize the broader implications of their writing.
  • Ultimately, by actively engaging with the principles and strategies outlined in “They Say / I Say,” mothers can empower their children to become proficient and confident writers, equipped to navigate the challenges of academic discourse with skill and poise.

Main Quotes Highlights

  • “The best academic writers are more like lawyers who argue for a position than like judges who decide what is right or wrong.”
  • “Good academic writing has one underlying feature: It is deeply engaged in some way with other people’s views.”

Reception or Critical Response to the Book

  • “They Say / I Say” has been widely praised for its clarity, accessibility, and effectiveness in teaching academic writing skills.
  • Educators and students alike have lauded its practical approach and the tangible improvements it fosters in writing proficiency.

Recommendations (Other Similar Books on the Same Topic)

  • “Writing Arguments: A Rhetoric with Readings” by John D. Ramage, John C. Bean, and June Johnson
  • “They Say / I Say”: The Moves That Matter in Academic Writing with Readings” by Gerald Graff and Cathy Birkenstein

They Say / I Say
Biggest Takeaway and Point in a Singular Sentence

They Say / I Say” equips readers with the essential tools and strategies to actively participate in academic discourse by mastering the art of responding to existing arguments, thereby enhancing their writing proficiency and confidence.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *